There’s a thought-provoking article at at AlThingsD that observes that the Mobile Tide is Turning Towards Full-Fledged Apps rather web-based technologies. It describes the case of Facebook and to a lesser extent Quora who have embraced native rather than web technologies.
The lesson here is that if you want the best user experience you have to go native. However, remember not everyone needs ‘the best experience’ and it’s possible to trade this for quicker, less expensive development and more flexible cross-platform deployment by using HTML5 development. I see the more dangerous scenario as one where a company takes on HTML5 development without really knowing they are making a tradeoff. Trying to get HTML close to the user experience of a native app costs a huge amount of effort that might as well have been spent on native apps. Conversely, if you know and accept, rather than fight, HTML5’s limitations then its advantages will be maximised.
There are three main areas to consider…
- Look and Feel: It’s possible to get HTML close to the look and feel of Android and iOS but it takes a considerable amount of effort due to browser fragmentation. If you want an Android/iOS look and feel then I would recommend you go native. If you want more of a custom, branded look then HTML will be ok.
- Functionality: If you are just displaying information then HTML5 is ok. If you are doing lots clever things with the information together with phone features (improving the user experience) you should go native as adding many of these things via web technologies ends up being either impossible or will require native code written anyway (e.g. for PhoneGap).
- Performance: The main issue here, for non-games, is usually scrolling. Less smooth scrolling is the tradeoff for using HTML5.
12 September UPDATE: Mark Zuckerberg admits wasting 2 years on HTML5
- Developer Garden Component Marketplace
- Web App Tips
- Web vs Native and the Enterprise
- Web for Discovery, App for Engagement
- Shoppers Prefer Web to Apps
- The Web, Apps and Social Media
- Mobile Frameworks Comparision Chart
- HTML5 vs Native
- Mobile Web Templates and Guidelines
- HTML5 Bits and Pieces
- Free Online Book on Android HTML5 Apps
- OS and Browser Fragmentation
- HTML5 Detection